For their daughter's first Thanksgiving Day the Olivers invited a
dozen friends to their Oakland house for dinner; the first really
large gathering of their married lives.
"We have always been too poor, or I haven't been well, or there's
been some other good reason for lying low," wrote Mrs. Oliver to
Mrs. Carroll, "but this year the stork is apparently filling
previous orders, and our trio is well, and we have been blessed
beyond all rhyme and reason, and want to give thanks. Anna and
Conrad and the O'Connors have promised, Jinny will be here, and I'm
only waiting to hear from you three to write and ask Phil and Mary
and Pillsey and the baby. So do come--for next year Anna says that
it's her turn, and by the year after we may be so prosperous that
I'll have to keep two maids, and miss half the fun--it will
certainly break my heart if I ever have to say, 'We'll have roast
turkey, Jane, and mince pies,' instead of making them myself. Please
come, we are dying to see the little cousins together, they will be
simply heavenly---"
"There's more than wearing your best dress and eating too much
turkey to Thanksgiving," said Susan to Billy, when they were
extending the dining-table to its largest proportions on the day
before Thanksgiving. "It's just one of those things, like having a
baby, that you have to do to appreciate. It's old-fashioned, and
homelike, and friendly. Perhaps I have a commonplace, middle-class
mind, but I do love all this! I love the idea of everyone arriving,
and a big fire down here, and Betts and her young man trying to
sneak away to the sun-room, and the boys sitting in Grandma's lap,
and being given tastes of white meat and mashed potato at
dinnertime. Me to the utterly commonplace, every time!"
"When you are commonplace, Sue," said her husband, coming out from
under the table, where hasps had been absorbing his attention,
"you'll be ready for the family vault at Holy Cross, and not one
instant before!"
"No, but the consolation is," Susan reflected, "that if this is
happiness,--if it makes me feel like the Lord Mayor's wife to have
three children, a husband whom most people think is either a saint
or a fool,--I think he's a little of both, myself!--and a new sun-
room built off my dining-room,--why, then there's an unexpected
amount of happiness in this world! In me--a plain woman, sir, with
my hands still odorous of onion dressing, and a safety-pin from my
daughter's bathing-struggle still sticking into my twelve-and-a-
half-cent gingham,--in me, I say, you behold a contented human
creature, who confidently hopes to live to be ninety-seven!"
"And then we'll have eternity together!" said the dusty Billy, with
an arm about her.
"And not a minute too long!" answered his suddenly serious wife.
"You absolutely radiate content, Sue," Anna said to her wistfully,
the next day.
Anna had come early to Oakland, to have luncheon and a few hours'
gossip with her hostess before the family's arrival for the six
o'clock dinner. The doctor's wife reached the gate in her own
handsome little limousine, and Susan had shared her welcome of Anna
with enthusiasm for Anna's loose great sealskin coat.
"Take the baby and let me try it on," said Susan. "Woman--it is the
most gorgeous thing I ever saw!"
"Conrad says I will need it in the east,--we go after Christmas,"
Anna said, her face buried against the baby.
Susan, having satisfied herself that what she really wanted, when
Billy's ship came in, was a big sealskin coat, had taken her guest
upstairs, to share the scuffle that preceded the boys' naps, and
hold Josephine while Susan put the big bedroom in order, and laid
out the little white suits for the afternoon.
Now the two women were sitting together, Susan in a rocker, with her
sleepy little daughter in the curve of her arm, Anna in a deep low
chair, with her head thrown back, and her eyes on the baby.
"Radiate happiness?" Susan echoed briskly, "My dear, you make me
ashamed. Why, there are whole days when I get really snappy and
peevish,--truly I do! running from morning until night. As for
getting up in the dead of night, to feed the baby, Billy says I look
like desolation--'like something the cat dragged in,' was his latest
pretty compliment. But no," Susan interrupted herself honestly, "I
won't deny it. I am happy. I am the happiest woman in the world."
"Yet you always used to begin your castles in Spain with a million
dollars," Anna said, half-wistfully, half-curiously. "Everything
else being equal, Sue," she pursued, "wouldn't you rather be rich?"
"Everything else never is equal," Susan answered thoughtfully. "I
used to think it was--but it's not! Now, for instance, take the case
of Isabel Wallace. Isabel is rich and beautiful, she has a good
husband,--to me he's rather tame, but probably she thinks of Billy
as a cave-man, so that doesn't count!--she has everything money can
buy, she has a gorgeous little boy, older than Mart, and now she has
a girl, two or three months old. And she really is a darling, Nance,
you never liked her particularly---"
"Well, she was so perfect," pleaded Anna smiling, "so gravely wise
and considerate and low-voiced, and light-footed---!"
"Only she's honestly and absolutely all of that!" Susan defended her
eagerly, "there's no pose! She really is unspoiled and good--my
dear, if the other women in her set were one-tenth as good as
Isabel! However, to go back. She came over here to spend the day
with me, just before Jo was born, and we had a wonderful day. Billy
and I were taking our dinners at a boarding-house, for a few months,
and Big Mary had nothing else to do but look out for the boys in the
afternoon. Isabel watched me giving them their baths, and feeding
them their lunches, and finally she said, 'I'd like to do that for
Alan, but I never do!' 'Why don't you?' I said. Well, she explained
that in the first place there was a splendid experienced woman paid
twenty-five dollars a week to do it, and that she herself didn't
know how to do it half as well. She said that when she went into the
nursery there was a general smoothing out of her way before her, one
maid handing her the talcum, another running with towels, and Miss
Louise, as they call her, pleasantly directing her and amusing Alan.
Naturally, she can't drive them all out; she couldn't manage without
them! In fact, we came to the conclusion that you have to be all or
nothing to a baby. If Isabel made up her mind to put Alan to bed
every night say, she'd have to cut out a separate affair every day
for it, rush home from cards, or from the links, or from the
matinee, or from tea--Jack wouldn't like it, and she says she doubts
if it would make much impression on Alan, after all!"
"I'd do it, just the same!" said Anna, "and I wouldn't have the
nurse standing around, either--and yet, I suppose that's not very
reasonable," she went on, after a moment's thought, "for that's
Conrad's free time. We drive nearly every day, and half the time
dine somewhere out of town. And his having to operate at night so
much makes him want to sleep in the morning, so that we couldn't
very well have a baby in the room. I suppose I'd do as the rest do,
pay a fine nurse, and grab minutes with the baby whenever I could!"
"You have to be poor to get all the fun out of children," Susan
said. "They're at their very sweetest when they get their clothes
off, and run about before their nap, or when they wake up and call
you, or when you tell them stories at night."
"But, Sue, a woman like Mrs. Furlong does not have to work so hard,"
Anna said decidedly, "you must admit that! Her life is full of ease
and beauty and power--doesn't that count? Doesn't that give her a
chance for self-development, and a chance to make herself a real
companion to her husband?" "Well, the problems of the world aren't
answered in books, Nance. It just doesn't seem interesting, or worth
while to me! She could read books, of course, and attend lectures,
and study languages. But--did you see the 'Protest' last week?"
"No, I didn't! It comes, and I put it aside to read--"
"Well, it was a corking number. Bill's been asserting for months,
you know, that the trouble isn't any more in any special class, it's
because of misunderstanding everywhere. He made the boys wild by
saying that when there are as many people at the bottom of the heap
reaching up, as there are people at the top reaching down, there'll
be no more trouble between capital and labor! And last week he had
statistics, he showed them how many thousands of rich people are
trying--in their entirely unintelligent ways!--to reach down, and--
my dear, it was really stirring! You know Himself can write when he
tries!--and he spoke of the things the laboring class doesn't do, of
the way it educates its children, of the way it spends its money,--
it was as good as anything he's ever done, and it made no end of
talk!
"And," concluded Susan contentedly, "we're at the bottom of the
heap, instead of struggling up in the world, we're struggling down!
When I talk to my girls' club, I can honestly say that I know some
of their trials. I talked to a mothers' meeting the other day, about
simple dressing and simple clothes for children, and they knew I had
three children and no more money than they. And they know that my
husband began his business career as a puddler, just as their sons
are beginning now. In short, since the laboring class can't,
seemingly, help itself, and the upper class can't help it, the
situation seems to be waiting for just such people as we are, who
know both sides!"
"A pretty heroic life, Susan!" Anna said shaking her head.
"Heroic? Nothing!" Susan answered, in healthy denial. "I like it!
I've eaten maple mousse and guinea-hen at the Saunders', and I've
eaten liver-and-bacon and rice pudding here, and I like this best.
Billy's a hero, if you like," she added, suddenly, "Did I tell you
about the fracas in August?"
"No-o-o! We fight," said Susan modestly, "when he thinks Mart ought
to be whipped and I don't, or when little Billums wipes sticky
fingers on his razor strop, but he ain't never struck me, mum, and
that's more than some can say! No, but this was really quite
exciting," Susan resumed, seriously. "Let me see how it began--oh,
yes!--Isabel Wallace's father asked Billy to dinner at the Bohemian
Club,--in August, this was. Bill was terribly pleased, old Wallace
introduced him to a lot of men, and asked him if he would like to be
put up---"
"Conrad would put him up, Sue---" Anna said jealously.
"My dear, wait--wait until you hear the full iniquity of that old
divil of a Wallace! Well, he ordered cocktails, and he 'dear boyed'
Bill, and they sat down to dinner. Then he began to taffy the
'Protest,' he said that the railroad men were all talking about it,
and he asked Bill what he valued it at. Bill said it wasn't for
sale. I can imagine just how graciously he said it, too! Well, old
Mr. Wallace laughed, and he said that some of the railroad men were
really beginning to enjoy the way Billy pitched into them; he said
he had started life pretty humbly himself; he said that he wanted
some way of reaching his men just now, and he thought that the
'Protest' was the way to do it. He said that it was good as far as
it went, but that it didn't go far enough. He proposed to work its
circulation up into hundreds of thousands, to buy it at Billy's
figure, and to pay him a handsome salary,--six thousand was hinted,
I believe,--as editor, under a five-year contract! Billy asked if
the policy of the paper was to be dictated, and he said, no, no,
everything left to him! Billy came home dazed, my dear, and I
confess I was dazed too. Mr. Wallace had said that he wanted Billy,
as a sort of side-issue, to live in San Rafael, so that they could
see each other easily,--and I wish you could see the house he'd let
us have for almost nothing! Then there would be a splendid round sum
for the paper, thirty or forty thousand probably, and the salary! I
saw myself a lady, Nance, with a 'rising young man' for a husband---
"
"But, Sue--but, Sue," Anna said eagerly, "Billy would be editor--
Billy would be in charge--there would be a contract--nobody could
call that selling the paper, or changing the policy of the
'Protest'---"
"Exactly what I said!" laughed Susan. "However, the next morning we
rushed over to the Cudahys--you remember that magnificent old person
you and Conrad met here? That's Clem. And his wife is quite as
wonderful as he is. And Clem of course tore our little dream to
rags---"
"Oh, in every way. He made it betrayal, and selling the birthright.
Billy saw it at once. As Clem said, where would Billy be the minute
they questioned an article of his, or gave him something for
insertion, or cut his proof? And how would the thing sound--a
railroad magnate owning the 'Protest'?"
"He might do more good that way than in any other," mourned Anna
rebelliously, "and my goodness, Sue, isn't his first duty to you and
the children?"
"Bill said that selling the 'Protest' would make his whole life a
joke," Susan said. "And now I see it, too. Of course I wept and
wailed, at the time, but I love greatness, Nance, and I truly
believe Billy is great!" She laughed at the artless admission.
"Well, you think Conrad is great," finished Susan, defending
herself.
"Yes, sometimes I wish he wasn't--yet," Anna said, sighing. "I never
cooked a meal for him, or had to mend his shirts!" she added with a
rueful laugh. "But, Sue, shall you be content to have Billy slave as
he is slaving now," she presently went on, "right on into middle-
age?"
"He'll always slave at something," Susan said, cheerfully, "but
that's another funny thing about all this fuss--the boys were simply
wild with enthusiasm when they heard about old Wallace and the
'Protest,' trust Clem for that! And Clem assured me seriously that
they'd have him Mayor of San Francisco yet!--However," she laughed,
"that's way ahead! But next year Billy is going east for two months,
to study the situation in different cities, and if he makes up his
mind to go, a newspaper syndicate has offered him enough money, for
six articles on the subject, to pay his expenses! So, if your angel
mother really will come here and live with the babies, and all goes
well, I'm going, too!"
"Mother would do anything for you," Anna said, "she loves you for
yourself, and sometimes I think that she loves you for--for Jo, you
know, too! She's so proud of you, Sue---"
"Well, if I'm ever anything to be proud of, she well may be!" smiled
Susan, "for, of all the influences of my life--a sentence from a
talk with her stands out clearest! I was moping in the kitchen one
day, I forget what the especial grievance was, but I remember her
saying that the best of life was service--that any life's happiness
may be measured by how much it serves!"
"True of us all! Georgie, and Alfie, and Virginia! And Mary Lou,--
did you know that they had a little girl? And Mary Lou just divides
her capacity for adoration into two parts, one for Ferd and one for
Marie-Louise!"
"Well, you're a delicious old theorist, Sue! But somehow you believe
in yourself, and you always do me good!" Anna said laughing. "I
share with Mother the conviction that you're rather uncommon--one
watches you to see what's next!"
"Putting this child in her crib is next, now," said Susan flushing,
a little embarrassed. She lowered Josephine carefully on the little
pillow. "Best--girl--her--mudder--ever--did--hab!" said Susan
tenderly as the transfer was accomplished. "Come on, Nance!" she
whispered, "we'll go down and see what Bill is doing."
So they went down, to add a score of last touches to the orderly,
homelike rooms, to cut grape-fruit and taste cranberry sauce, to
fill vases with chrysanthemums and ferns, and count chairs for the
long table.
"This is fun!" said Susan to her husband, as she filled little
dishes with nuts and raisins in the pantry and arranged crackers on
a plate.
"You bet your life it's fun!" agreed Billy, pausing in the act of
opening a jar of olives. "You look so pretty in that dress, Sue," he
went on, contentedly, "and the kids are so good, and it seems dandy
to be able to have the family all here! We didn't see this coming
when we married on less than a hundred a month, did we?"
He put his arm about her, they stood looking out of the window
together.
"We did not! And when you were ill, Billy--and sitting up nights
with Mart's croup!" Susan smiled reminiscently.
"And the Thanksgiving Day the milk-bill came in for five months--
when we thought we'd been paying it!"
"We've been through some times, Bill! But isn't it wonderful to--to
do it all together--to be married?"
"You bet your life it's wonderful," agreed the unpoetic William.
"It's the loveliest thing in the world," his wife said dreamily. She
tightened his arm about her and spoke half aloud, as if to herself.
"It is the Great Adventure!" said Susan.